How to Choose the Best Pasta: A Nutritionist’s Guide to Health, Taste and Digestion

As an Italian nutritionist, I often hear the same questions: “Is pasta bad for me?”, “Why does pasta make me bloated?”, or “Should I avoid gluten completely?”. Pasta has been unfairly demonized in recent years, but the truth is simple: pasta, in moderation, is not harmful. The key lies in choosing the right type. Understanding how different pasta varieties affect digestion, gut health and even taste allows us to enjoy this staple of the Mediterranean diet without guilt.

Is Pasta Good for You?

Yes—when chosen wisely, pasta can be part of a balanced diet. High-quality pasta provides slow-release carbohydrates, plant protein, and can be an excellent vehicle for nutrient-rich sauces and vegetables. What matters is portion size and the type of wheat used.

Why Does Pasta Make Me Bloated?

Many people believe gluten is to blame, but the science tells a more complex story. Research comparing old and modern wheat varieties shows that:

  • Gluten peptides vary depending on the wheat used. Surprisingly, older wheat often produces more potentially immunogenic peptides than modern varieties. “Ancient” does not always mean gentler on the gut.

  • In people with IBS, the real culprit is often FODMAPs, particularly fructans, which ferment in the gut and cause bloating, gas, and discomfort.

  • Other wheat proteins such as amylase-trypsin inhibitors (ATIs) can also trigger digestive reactions in sensitive individuals.

Cooking pasta al dente—firm to the bite rather than overcooked—can make a real difference. Al dente pasta has a lower glycemic index, meaning the starch is digested more slowly. Slower digestion can reduce rapid fermentation in the gut, helping to minimize bloating and digestive discomfort. Some evidence also suggests that undercooked or al dente pasta may slightly reduce gluten reactivity compared with very soft, overcooked pasta, although this is not a substitute for medical guidance in celiac disease.

This means that bloating after pasta is not always about gluten itself. For sensitive individuals, portion control, choosing low-FODMAP alternatives, and cooking pasta al dente can significantly improve comfort.

Old vs. Modern Wheat: Does It Matter?

Pasta is traditionally made from durum wheat, but not all durum is the same. Studies comparing old and modern varieties highlight important differences:

  • Older durum wheats such as Cappelli and Trinakria generally have a higher protein content, which gives pasta more bite and better satiety. They often produce firmer spaghetti that holds its shape when cooked.

  • Modern wheats have been bred for stronger gluten proteins and higher yields, but this sometimes comes with slightly lower protein percentages. The result can be pasta that is more elastic in dough form but not always superior in cooking quality.

  • The balance between gliadins and glutenins—the two main types of gluten proteins—affects both texture and digestibility. Stronger gluten does not necessarily mean more nutritious pasta.

Taste, Texture and Production Methods

From a culinary perspective, quality is not just about wheat genetics. The way pasta is produced matters. Bronze-cut pasta, often made from high-protein durum wheat, has a rougher surface that clings to sauce and delivers a more authentic “al dente” texture. Slow drying at low temperatures also preserves both taste and nutritional integrity.

In contrast, industrial pasta made with high-yield wheat and rapid drying methods may lose some of the firmness and character that make traditional pasta so satisfying.


Debunking Common Pasta Myths

  • “Pasta is fattening.” Pasta alone is not fattening; portion size and heavy sauces are the real issue.

  • “Gluten-free pasta is healthier.” Unless you have celiac disease, gluten-free options are not automatically better. They are often lower in protein and higher in starch.

  • “Ancient grains are always safer.” Scientific studies show that some old wheat varieties release more immunogenic gluten peptides than modern wheats.

Practical Tips for Choosing the Best Pasta

  • For everyday meals, select durum wheat pasta with higher protein content, ideally bronze-cut and slow-dried.

  • For sensitive digestion or IBS, experiment with smaller portions, al dente cooking, or low-FODMAP pasta alternatives such as rice, corn, or quinoa blends.

  • For nutritional variety, occasionally rotate in wholegrain or legume-based pasta for extra fiber and plant protein.

Pasta is not the enemy. It is a central part of the Mediterranean diet and, when chosen carefully, it can be both nourishing and deeply satisfying. By understanding the differences between wheat varieties, protein quality and production methods, you can guide your clients toward choices that support gut health, improve digestion and preserve the joy of eating.

So, is pasta good for you? Absolutely—when eaten in moderation and chosen with care.